Executive Search Insights & Leadership Strategies | Edgility Search

What Does an Open Leadership Seat Cost? (More Than the Search)

Written by Admin | Nov 17, 2026, 6:01:10 PM

The number boards don't see

When a board is deciding whether to hire a search firm, the conversation almost always comes down to the fee. What does this firm charge compared to that one? Could we run it ourselves and save the money? The fee is the one cost in a leadership transition that shows up as a line item, so it gets all the attention.

What doesn't show up is everything the organization loses while the seat is empty. We built the Cost of Vacancy Calculator to put a number on it. You can try it yourself; it takes a couple of minutes to see your results, and you can adjust the assumptions to get the most accurate calculation.

What the calculator counts

The calculator looks at four costs that don't typically show up a budget report, to get you the true cost of a vacancy. Without considering these cost, a vacancy can feel less expensive than it is.

The first is coverage. Someone has to do the job while you search. If that's a paid interim leader, you're usually paying more than the budgeted salary. If it's someone already on staff, it is likely that part of their own job isn't getting done or they are significantly over capacity.

The second, and usually the biggest, is the work that waits. The senior hire nobody can approve, the strategic plan sitting on a shelf, the partnership no one has the authority to sign. Day to day things can feel fine, but very little is moving forward.

The third is staff turnover. People who report to an open role are more likely to leave, and every departure turns into another hire you didn't plan for.

The fourth applies to executive directors and CEOs, and it's fundraising. Donors often hold off on renewing or growing a gift until they've met the new leader. Even a small dip in a month's giving adds up quickly.

You can also subtract the salary you aren't paying while the seat is open, and I'd encourage you to try it. For most senior roles, the number stays well above zero.

An example

Say you're a nonprofit with a $180,000 executive director role, an interim in place, ten people reporting to the ED, and $2 million a year in fundraising. Using the calculator's default assumptions, that open seat costs about $28,900 a month.

Cost

Per month

How it's estimated

Stalled decisions and projects

$15,000

One month of the role's salary

Fundraising slippage

$8,333

5% of a month's contributed revenue

Interim premium

$4,500

30% above the budgeted salary

Staff turnover risk

$1,073

10 people, 0.5% added monthly chance of leaving, 33% replacement cost on a $65,000 salary

Total

$28,906

About $347,000 a year

That's close to $350,000 a year. Our searches take a median of 22 weeks from signed contract to an accepted offer, and then your new leader has a notice period to work through. If this board launched a search today, the seat would likely be open about seven more months, or roughly $210,000. Every month it waits to decide adds another $28,900. Set next to that, a $65,000 search fee works out to about ten weeks of vacancy. 

What actually brings the number down

Once a board sees the monthly cost, the question tends to change. It becomes less about which option costs least and more about how to get the right person into the seat and keep them there.

Starting sooner is the most obvious lever. Nothing about a search gets easier with time, and every month of waiting is another month of the costs above.

Getting to real candidates quickly matters too. At Edgility, our median time to a first slate is eight weeks. That's the point where a search committee stops speculating about who's out there and starts making choices.

The biggest lever is getting it right the first time. A hire who leaves in year one doesn't just mean a second fee. It means starting every one of these costs over, usually with a team that's more worn down than the first time around. That's why we pay so much attention to retention: 80% of the leaders we've placed are still in their roles two years later.

I'll be honest about the do-it-ourselves option, too. When we looked back at the searches we didn't win last year, schools most often told us they had decided to run the search internally. Sometimes that's the right call. But a board-run search competes with everyone's day job, which creates delays. If you're weighing that route, try the calculator with a few extra months of vacancy and see what the difference is.

Using your results with your board

The boards that get the most out of the calculator treat the result as the start of a conversation, not a verdict. Run it before the meeting with your real salary, coverage, and team size, and leave any assumption you aren't sure about at the default. They're set on the conservative side.

Then request the emailed breakdown and send it to your treasurer. It lists every line item and assumption, along with a short paragraph you can drop straight into a board memo.

It also pairs well with our Search Launch Date Calculator, which works backward from the day you want a new leader in place to the day your search should launch. Between the two, you'll have answers to the questions boards ask most: what is waiting costing us, and when do we need to start?

 

Hadley Kornacki is the Chief Operating Officer of Edgility Search, a women-owned executive search firm that partners with schools, nonprofits, and mission-driven organizations to find, hire, and keep their leaders.